Home Game Reviews Professor Evil and the Citadel of Time Review

Professor Evil and the Citadel of Time Review

1028
3
Board Game Review by: :
Tony Mastrangeli
Price:
$27

Reviewed by:
Rating:
3.5
On Nov 28, 2017
Last modified:Nov 28, 2017

Summary:

Professor Evil Review

Professor Evil and the Citadel of TimeI’ll say this about games published by Funforge, they sure know how to make them pretty. Just browsing through their catalog is a virtual cornucopia of fantastic art and vibrant colors. So it’s no wonder than I had to stop and take notice of Professor Evil and the Citadel of Time when I wandered past it at Gen Con 2017.

Professor Evil and the Citadel of Time (simply Professor Evil from here on for brevity’s sake) is a cooperative heist game for 2-4 players that takes about 30 minutes to play. It plays well at all player counts.

Gameplay Overview:

The goal in Professor Evil is to rescue 4 treasures before the Professor can lock enough away. Each player will get to control a unique character, each of which specializes in a specific area of the game (movement, locks, etc…). Once the board is seeded with switches and treasures, you are ready to begin.

Professor Evil Treasure
Each treasure will require specific switches be set to off before you can collect it.

A players turn has 3 phases:

  1. Reveal the top two cards of your player deck
  2. Take 3 actions and play one of your revealed cards (optional). Different actions included moving, unlocking a door, flipping a switch, or rescuing a treasure.
    To rescue a treasure, all the switches listed on the treasure tile must be set to their off position. Once rescued, a new treasure is added to the Citadel, so that there are always 3 in play.
  3. Roll the dice, which determines what the Professor does that turn and how the clock moves.

One set of dice will move the professor around the board. If he moves through an unlocked door, he locks it. If he moves into a room with an off switch, he turns it on, and if he encounters a player, they are kicked outside the Citadel. The other die will move the clock marker one or two paces. If the clock marker ever reaches a treasure marker, the professor locks that treasure away in his vault.

The game ends when the players have rescued the 4th treasure, or the Professor has secured his 4th treasure token.

Professor Evil Game Experience
If the time marker ever reaches a treasure token, the Professor locks it away in his vault.

Game Experience:

One thing I really loved about Professor Evil was what a breeze it was to teach. Between that and the easy setup, you can be up and gaming in a few minutes. Since Professor Evil is a fairly light game, this helped to get it to the table somewhat often. While I wouldn’t call it a filler game, it’s definitely going to stick to the lighter end of the complexity spectrum. And when you combine that with its cooperative nature, Professor Evil ends up being a great family game in the same vein as the Forbidden Island/Desert series of games.

Professor Evil Player Cards
Each player has a deck of six unique cards.

Setting aside the stellar visuals, one of my favorite things about Professor Evil has to be the unique player decks. While there are only 6 cards in a player deck, each character feels wholly unique. One character is really good at movement, another can easily deal with locks, and there is even one who embraces randomness in everything she does. This helps up the replay value as you are going to want to try out every character.

At its heart though, Professor Evil feels almost like a puzzle game. Sure there is randomness in the game (more on that in a second), but a lot of the game is centered around which treasures to collect and how best to make that happen. As you are racing against the Professor, a lot of the table talk will center around optimizing your actions. Player X needs to go here and flip this switch, allowing Player Y to snatch up the loot.

Professor Evil Dice
Thanks to the random nature of the dice, the game will have a high luck factor.

However, going against that puzzle-like nature of the game is how luck dependent everything is. When a treasure comes out, there is always a chance that every needed switch will already be set to off, allowing for an easy collection. Controversy, the dice determine what the professor does, and more than once I’ve seen him camp out in the same room for a few turns, essentially blocking players from even having a chance at getting a specific treasure. This can sometimes be very frustrating when you have no way to mitigate an unlucky dice roll.

The other thing to be aware of with Professor Evil is that it’s not a very hard game to win. We’ve played a handful of times already and never lost. I will say that most of the games are very close, usually 4-3 wins, so it’s not like it’s been a cakewalk. However I never really felt under the gun in the game. In some co-ops, you will feel like you are constantly treading water just to stay afloat. Professor Evil just doesn’t have that feeling. On the other hand, that’s probably one of the reasons this is a great family game. Your young ones are probably less likely to pout when they come away with a win.

Final Thoughts:

Despite the glut of cooperative games coming out every year, Professor Evil and the Citadel of Time still managed to feel fresh and enjoyable. I really enjoyed the unique player decks and the great production values. I think its 30 minute play time is pretty spot on, as anything more than that and the game would probably start to feel repetitive.

If you are in the market for a lightweight or family co-op game, Professor Evil and the Citadel of Time will certainly fit the bill. Despite being another entry in a crowded genre, it still manages to stand out on its own. If you can live with some of its quirks, you can have a good time looting the Citadel.

Final Score: 3.5 Stars – A fun, puzzle-like heist game with some great production values, just be aware of the randomness in the game.

3.5 StarsHits:
• Excellent Visuals
• Unique player decks
• Puzzle-like gameplay

Misses:
• High degree of randomness
• Doesn’t have the tension found in many coops.

Get Your Copy

SHARE

While he will play just about anything, Tony loves games that let him completely immerse himself in the theme. He also is a bit of a component addict.

3 COMMENTS

  1. Hi Tony, thanks for this review.
    For some reason, there seem to be widely different opinions regarding the difficulty of the game. I’ve seen people describing it as impossible, and others as too easy, and I wonder if both sides are getting all the rules right.
    In your case, you write that “when a treasure comes out, there is always a chance that every needed switch will already be set to off, allowing for an easy collection”. But can you confirm that, when you were rescuing a treasure, you were resetting all the switches depicted on that treasure?
    It sounds like this rule was introduced late in the development process to adjust the difficulty based on playtests, and is frequently missed.
    I haven’t played the game myself, so it might not change much, but I was wondering.
    The look/theme of this game appeals to me much more than Pandemic’s, and ‘m considering adding it to my family’s collection (we don’t have any co-op yet), but if it’s really too much on the easy side and lacks tension, this might be a deal breaker.

    • Hi Pierre,
      Thanks for the heads up. I was aware of that rule and I can believe it’s easily missed. While it is rare that a treasure already has all switches off, I have seen it happen (especially at the start of the game), this usually happens with the easier treasures that only have 1 or maybe 2 switches. Once again, luck of the draw. 🙂

      Again, it’s a fun game and I do enjoy it. But the randomness is something to be aware of.

      • Thanks a lot for clarifying.
        And I should correct myself: one of the designers explained in a post on BGG that this rule about resetting the switches was not a late addition to the design, but was somehow miscommunicated at early demoes, resulting in people being taught the game wrong.
        Anyway thanks again for a great article, and for what has become one of my favourite boardgame related websites. Keep up the good work!

Leave a Comment