Home Games by Rating

Games by Rating

Looking for a new game to add to your collection? Maybe something new for that upcoming game night? Here are all the games we’ve reviewed, in order by their rating.

Here is a quick break down of our rating system:
5 Stars – Fantastic Game, A must-play game.
4-4.5 Stars – Great Game, might have some minor flaws.
3-3.5 Stars – Good Game. Does a lot right, but also has some weaknesses.
2-2.5 Stars – OK Game. Some redeeming qualities, but outweighed by the negatives.
1-1.5 Stars – Awful Game. Do not play this unless you want to punish yourself.

5 Stars: Fantastic Game

57 Wonders
5Allegiance: A Realm Divided
5 The Battle of Five Armies
5Battlestar Galactica
5 – Carcassonne
5Dungeons and Dragons 5th Edition Monster Manual
5Five Tribes
5Great Western Trail
5Imperial Settlers
5Istanbul
5Mombasa
5Neuroshima Hex 3.0
5 – Netrunner
5 – Pandemic
5Pandemic: Legacy
5Rampage
5Rhino Hero
5 – Star Wars: X-Wing Miniatures
5 – Suburbia
5 – The Settlers of Catan
5Ticket to Ride: Europe

4.5 Stars: Great Game

4.54 Gods
4.5
Adventure Land
4.5Arcane Academy
4.5
Argent: The Consortium
4.5Bruges
4.5Cash ‘N Guns 2e
4.5 – Chaos in the Old World
4.5Colt Express
4.5Cry Havoc
4.5Cthulhu Wars
4.5Discoveries
4.5Dominion
4.5 – Dungeons and Dragons 5th Edition Dungeon Master’s Guide
4.5Dungeons and Dragons 5th Edition Player’s Handbook
4.5El Grande Big Box
4.5Eldritch Horror
4.5Freedom: The Underground Railroad
4.5Glass Road
4.5The Grizzled
4.5Hanabi
4.5Hold Your Breath
4.5Ice Cool
4.5Junk Art
4.5Karuba
4.5Kingsburg
4.5Lords of Waterdeep
4.5Machina Arcana
4.5The Manhattan Project
4.5 – Millennium Blades
4.5Mound Builders
4.5Mysterium
4.5The Networks
4.5Pandemic: The Cure
4.5Quarto
4.5Relic Runners
4.5Risk: Legacy
4.5Sentinels of the Multiverse
4.5Slaughterball
4.5Space Alert
4.5Space Cadets: Dice Duel
4.5Takenoko
4.5Tide of Iron
4.5Tides of Madness
4.5TIME Stories
4.5Trieste
4.5Two Rooms and a Boom
4.5Tyrants of the Underdark
4.5Viceroy
4.5Vikings

4 Stars: Great Game

47 Wonders: Duel
4
51st State Master Set
4Adrenaline
4Animal Upon Animal
4Animal Upon Animal: Crest Climbers
4Abyss
4Alchemists
4Ancient Terrible Things
4ApocalypZe
4Battle Merchants
4Belfort
4Beyond Baker Street
4Black Fleet
4Blood Bowl: Team Manager
4The Bloody Inn
4 – Builders of Blankenburg
4Capo dei Capi
4Carcassonne: South Seas
4Cards Against Humanity
4Civilization: The Board Game
4Clank!
4Coconuts
4 – CVlizations
4Dead Men Tell No Tales
4Deadwood
4Dragon Punch
4 – Dungeon Lords
4Eight Minute Empire
4Eminent Domain: Microcosm
4Euphoria
4Fairy Tale
4Final Touch
4Firefly: The Game
4Forbidden Desert
4Friday
4Fuse
4 – A Game of Thrones: Hand of the King
4 – Ghost Stories
4Glory to Rome
4Gravwell: Escape From the 9th Dimension
4Hands in the Sea
4Histrio
4Hit Z Road
4Homeland: The Game
4Hundred Days 20
4Jungle Ascent
4 – Jungle Speed
4K2
4 – Kill Doctor Lucky: Deluxe 19.5th Anniversary Edition
4The King’s Armory
4 – Kingdom Builder
4Lanterns: The Harvest Festival
4Legacy: The Testament of Duke de Crecy
4Legendary: Marvel Deck Building Game
4Loony Quest
4Intrigue
4Marvel Dice Masters
4Memoir ’44
4Nevermore
4Orcs Must Die: The Board Game
4Pairs
4Paperback
4Periorbis
4Pixel Tactics
4 – Police Precinct
4 – The Resistance: Avalon
4Rise of Cthulhu
4Sellswords
4Shadowrun: Crossfire
4Snow Tails
4Spyrium
4Star Trek: Ascendancy
4Star Trek: Panic
4Star Wars: Destiny
4 – Star Wars: The Queen’s Gambit
4Terra Mystica
4Tides of Time
4Traders of Osaka
4Treasure Hunter
4 – Trickerion: Legends of Illusion
4Ultimate Warriorz
4Via Nebula
4Viticulture
4WWE Superstar Showdown
4Xia: Legends of the Drift System
4Zombicide

3.5 Stars: Good Game

3.5 – And Then We Held Hands
3.5The Agents
3.5 – Alhambra
3.5Antarctica 
3.5Between Two Cities
3.5Boss Monster
3.5Captain Carcass
3.5Catacombs
3.5 – Click Clack Lumberjack
3.5Concept
3.5 – Dungeon Fighter
3.5Dungeon Petz
3.5Feed the Shoggoth!
3.5Fidelitas
3.5Flip City
3.5Fool’s Gold
3.5Galactic Strike Force
3.5Gears of War
3.5Godfather: A New Don
3.5 – Gunrunners
3.5Hegemonic
3.5Heir to the Pharoah
3.5Horus Heresy
3.5Hoyuk
3.5Infiltration
3.5Kahuna
3.5Kings of Artifice
3.5 – Last Will
3.5 – Legacy: Gears of Time
3.5Libertalia
3.5Lost Woods
3.5Machi Koro
3.5Meteor
3.5Mice and Mystics
3.5Mistfall
3.5Metro 2033: Breakthrough
3.5oddball Aeronauts
3.5Operation F.A.U.S.T.
3.5Pathfinder Adventure Card Game
3.5Pagoda
3.5Pocket Madness
3.5Port Royal
3.5Pyramix
3.5Red7
3.5Rollet
3.5 – Seasons
3.5Settlers of America – Trails to Rails
3.5Splendor
3.5Star Realms
3.5Steam Time
3.5Sushi Go!
3.5Tash-Kalar: Arena of Legends
3.5Terraforming Mars
3.5Tokaido
3.5Tomorrow
3.5Tzolk’in: The Mayan Calendar
3.5Ulm
3.5V-Wars

3 Stars: Good Game

3 – 3 Wishes
3
7-Card Slugfest
3Back to the Future: An Adventure Through Time
3Bountytown
3Captain’s Wager
3Carrotia
3 – Castle Panic
3Coup
3Cube Quest
3CV
3 – Dastardly Dirigibles
3 – Elfenland
3Elysium
3Epic Resort
3Fishing Party
3Garbage Day
3Get Rich Quick
3 – Guillotine
3Happy Party
3Harry Potter Hogwarts Battle
3Impulse
3Incredibrawl
3 – King of Tokyo
3Knuckling Knights
3The Last Spike
3Lords and Ladies
3Martian Dice
3New World: A Carcassonne Game
3 – No Thanks!
3Pew Pew!
3Quixx
3Road Kill Rally
3Rattle, Battle, Grab the Loot
3Raid & Trade
3Scripts & Scribes: The Dice Game
3Skyline
3Tanks: Panthers vs. Sherman
3 Those Pesky Humans
3Titan Race
3 – Titans Tactics
3 – Tumult Royale

2 – 2.5 Stars: OK Game

2.5Agricola: Family Edition
2.5
Aquadukt
2.5Back to the Future: Outatime
2.5Bad Beets
2.5Bad Neighbors
2.5The Castles of Burgundy
2.5 Damage Report
2.5Dodge Dice
2.5Farmageddon
2.5 – Fief: France 1429
2.5For The Win
2.5I Say, Holmes!
2.5Microfilms
2.5Nations: The Dice Game
2.5Pittsburg 68
2.5Stick to Colours
2.5Theomachy
2.5Ticket to Ride: Rails and Sails
2Age of War
2Cross Hares: Testing Ground
2 – Over/Under
2Patchistory
2Stronghold: 2nd Edition
2Tambuzi
2Warehouse 51
2 – Zombies!!!

1.5 – 1 Star: Awful Game

1.5 – The Amberden Affair
1.5
Blurble
1.5Empires at Sea
1.5Hengist
1.5 – Necronomicards
1.5Red November
1.5Super Dungeon Explore
1.5World War Z: The Game

Expansions: (Rated on Buy, Optional, Pass)

Buy Abyss: Kraken
Buy – Betrayal at House on the Hill: Widow’s Walk Expansion
BuyColt Express: Horses and Stagecoach
BuyFirefly: Kalidasa
Buy Last Will: Getting Sacked
Buy
Lords of Waterdeep: Scoundrels of Skullport
BuyThe Manhattan Project: Nations Expansion
BuyThe Manhattan Project: Second Stage Expansion
BuyPixel Tactics 2
BuyPixel Tactics 3
BuySpace Cadets: Dice Duel – Die Fighter Expansion
BuySuburbia Inc.
BuyTakenoko: Chibis
BuyTide of Iron: Stalingrad
Optional7 Wonders: Babel
Optional – Dungeon Lords: Festival Season
OptionalNeuroshima Hex Dancer
OptionalStar Realms: Crisis
OptionalTicket to Ride: Nederland

Children’s Games: (Rated separately from adult games)

4 – Hide the Kids!
4 – Zombie Kidz

iOS Games

5Ticket to Ride
5 – Heroes of Normandie
5Neuroshima Hex
4.5Agricola: All Creatures Big and Small
4.5Brass
4.5Cthulhu Realms
4.5Desert Fox
4.5Lords of Waterdeep
4.5Pandemic
4.5Patchwork
4Can’t Stop
4Cahoots
4Drive on Moscow
4Quarriors
4Splendor
3.5 A Brief History of the World
3Colt Express
3LeHavre: The Inland Port
3Mars Needs Mechanics
3The Settlers of Catan
3The Witcher Adventure Game
-1Wits and Wagers